About the approach of Muslim Scholars

Most of the explanations by Muslim scholars are logical speculations and not something from Quran- the religious book of Islam. They have done a copy paste job from their predecessors but in modern language. Quran has only "Surah Ikhlas" but it talks about some properties of God not the logical fallacies which they associate with Him using the arguments of the Arab "Biladushami" demagogues. They use this  technique to intellectualise any of their own concepts or misconcption. This is what the absurd " Ilmul Kalam" is all about. The properties attributed to God are subject to faith and not proof. If there exists no such god then all their self conceived properties to god will be in vain. So before associating any property to god one has to make sure about god's concept and his existence in the first place.

Pashtun National Struggle and Religion

The target of Pakhtun political parties is political and not religious in nature, hence what they talk about is only in political context. It has nothing to do with the version of religion being followed by the oppressed or the oppressors. They are against those, who might even fly due to the caliber of their faith, if they usurp our rights and they have no debate with those who might even consider us non Muslims as long as they assure not to violate our human rights. For example the resilience to Kalabagh dam in Pakistan has nothing to do whether you worship graves or you are Wahhabi or ahle hadith or ahle Quran or whatever. No political party or group will ever bother about this absurd debate. Pakhtun political parties should oppose the Muslims of Punjab and of the same sect as that of Pashtuns if they usurp our rights but we wont bother anyone even though they might have a different sect or religion but if they don’t dare to usurp our rights. Pashtuns don't need any Pashtun Nationalism in Afghanistan but rather Afghan nationalism which means safeguarding the sovereignty, respect, and rights of Afghans. Pakhtun Nationalism is however needed in occupied Pakhtunkhwa to win freedom from the those who have occupied Pashtuns land and resources for the last 63 years.

Questions from the dead souls

Do you expect that a person who is on the verge of losing his or her life due to the criminal negligence of  Pakistani civil or military bureaucracy and technocrats  will raise his or her voice? Do you expect any response form masses despite the fact that they have been indoctrinated with a status-quo version of religion by the mullah most of whom are backed by the state? Do you expect any enlightened thoughts from those who have been victims of  Taliban rule which was imposed with the help of Pakistani intelligence agencies? Do you expect any voice of freedom from oppressed nations in Pakistan for example Pashtuns who have been deprived of even their name for 63 years, whose resource have been exploited during all these years and who have been indoctrinated with a false version of history and politics? Do you really not see those sellouts who sell their souls to the power elite of Pakistan ? How can you keep praying more than five times a day  while your sisters, brothers, mothers and elders are dying and drowning and being humiliated by the state? How can you convince yourself that you are just one person and can’t do anything when all those awareness movements and achievement started but with one person. Gandhi was one person, Bacha khan was one person, Ahmed shah baba was one and so were all other sons of soil. Do you not exist as a human entity? Do you not understand that if every nation were so much politically conscious then there would not have been any need for a freedom movement? Think some time while you are introspecting in solitude.

God Knows better

Saying God knows better is the type of response which does not give us any information either to analyse the cause of an incident or the means to find a solution to the problem. By attributing physical incidents to metaphysical ones we are doing nothing except putting a period to any scientific inquiry into the causes of such incidents and hence devoiding our people or humanity at large of a possible solution. No wonder the whole Muslim world have nothing to add to the knowledge base of humanity except the phrase " Wallaho aalam bissawaab" [God knows better].

US Ambassador on AfpAK issues

The recent statement of  US ambassdor Richard Holbrook to Pakistan and Afghanistan was misinterpreted by many. In my opinion what he meant between the lines in the language of diplomacy was very dangerous for Pakistan but was not understood by those who have been  hypnotised by Noor Jahan's songs and Jeevay Jeevay Pakistan slogans instead of knowing history of International relations. It will be naive to think that Richard Holbrooke was justifying the strategic depth policy of Pakistan in Afghanistan. What he meant in reality was :

Before the problem [terrorism] is inter-nationalised [and west specially US gets affected again] it is better to address the root of the problem - which is Pakistan's interest in Afghanistan. Now Pakistan due to its weak state structure and political economy too cannot handle the probem of terrorism by herself hence US intervention [and in later stage military presence] is necessary in Pakistan. So Pakistan's role in Afghanistan can be accepted [if Pakistan accepts the role of US in Pakistan willingly].

My analysis is that the basic stance of Pakistan army about strategic depth was due to Pakistan's India-centric policies [recently even spelt out loud by Kayani] which have been refuted by all analysts of substance even in Pakistan [Punjab] like Najam Sethi of Daily Times or Kamran Shafi of Dawn etc. On the other hand ,after going through 30 years of war and witnissing the prophecies of real national heroes like Dr Najib coming true , the invincilbe Afghans will never accept legitimate or illigitimate role of anyone as the current generation of Afghans is much politically aware than ever before.

Youtube Videos about Afghans

There is an negative propaganda about Pashtuns on the internet by the enslaved Pakhtuns of Pakistan against the Afghans to create a rift between them across the Durand line. It will be highly appreciated if these agents of Punjabi empire [in the garb of Pashtuns] post the videos of Pakistan army and their agencies insulting and defaming Pashtuns and specially tribal Pashtuns in the name of operations on the Internet. Posting anti Afghan videos, on the contrary, makes the role of these so called Pakhtuns dubious instead of showing their sincerity with Pashtuns/Afghans. The best way to achieve the goal of Freedom for Pakhtuns, which such imposters advocate in the garb of being a royally screwed loyalist of Pakistani agencies,  is to make Pakhtuns aware of their rights in the federation of Pakistan and how Pakhtuns are deprived of their rights by the ruling elite of Punjab. If these so called Pakistani [or Punjabised] Pakhtuns cannot help achieve freedom for Pakhtuns then all their activities constitute a conscious effort to sabotage the endevours of the sincere Pakhtuns struggling for the liberty and freedom of their enslaved nation in Pakistan.

Revolutionary Political Ideas in Pakistan

Pakistan is an army owned autocratic state not a republic; hence it is beyond common sense for any revolutionary to announce revolutionary ideas in writing. How can one expect the Nationalist political parties to announce their ultimate goal [establishment of Pakhtunistan and its ultimate merger with its parent land Afghanistan] in their manifesto when the manifesto is scrutinised by the Election commission of Pakistan? Even a low IQ person understands that it is considered anti-state to announce rebellious ideas publically or in writing in any state with some form of a constitution, however ineffective it might be. As far as revolutionary struggle is concerned, anybody who knows the abc of revolutionary politics knows this fact that revolutionary struggle is always invisible and within silent majority by a minority and in person or in the form of disseminating literature. It is when the passive resistance from within the silent majority turns into active resistance at the grand finale of the movement that the struggle is visible by the masses.

Having said that let me assure you that I am dead sure the people wont have to do much to get freedom. The internal system of Pakistan, being a classic case of contradictions within itself, and the fading international rapport of Pakistan coupled with its increasing geostrategic importance will force the international forces to intervene in one form or another to help Pakistan meet its logical end and ofcourse other than North Punjabi elite class no one is bothered about Pakistan due to their loss of interest in such a life which the state of Pakistan offers to its citizen. This is not being critical but being realistic.  Just observe the number of  increasing suicides in Pakistan in cases where the parents are killing their own kids as they can’t feed them. 

I wish the optimistic arguments along with their intellectual justifications of Punjabi loyalists could save the lives of those kids who could not even see the luxury of being in debt for your country and lost their life due to having been born in this failed rogue state. No offence intended it is in the interest of humanity and the 180 million lives that Pakistan should not exist anymore even for purely humanitarian reasons. "Pakistan Zinda bad" has practically turned into "Pakistan say zinda bhaag".

Bringing Afghan Taliban into mainstream Politics

There is an intrinsic contradiction which is like a mathematical indeterminate form in the indigenous Taliban of Afghanistan [if any] and that is the version of religion they believe in. More than 95 percent of Afghans belong to and practice Hanafi School of jurisprudence while those Taliban who have been under the influence of Arabs [and hold an influential position] are all predominantly Wahabi [Non-followers of the recognized scholars of juristic schools]. Hence there is a non reconcilable contradiction in their schools of thought. Inviting the Taliban who have been trained under the pro-Punjab [army] mindset to become a part of political process and contribute to the progress of Afghanistan, which they consider ideologically incorrect will be an exercise in futility and against the strategy of resolving statecraft related issues. The solution to bring Taliban into mainstream in my opinion lies in focusing on the ideological handicaps of Taliban which will bring positive results in bringing peace to Afghanistan and the region. Pakistan should do away with their dream that Afghanistan will accept its dictation about foreign policy. Pakistan's allegation that Afghanistan is being used against its soil is baseless not because the Baloch are not hiding in Afghanistan but due to two reasons:

i) The Baloch struggle for freedom whether being supported or not by x or y is an indigenous struggle due to the atrocities of Pakistan army in Baluchistan for decades and this fact has been recognized even by the Punjab based PML[N] which is one of the two larger parties in Pakistan and their support for giving rights to Baochistan atleast by saying so if not acting accordingly in addition to the their support for the illegal and unethical targeted killing of Akbar Bugti by military under Musharraf.

ii) Pakistan criticises the presence of Indian embassies in South Afghanistan while forgets to put an end to the training camps set up by Pakistan military near the Durand line from where 80 percent of resistance is being offered to 80 percent security forces to destablise Afghanistan. Pakistan always dreams of installing a pro-Pakistan puppet govt of religious clergy with no leadership skills to keep Afghans subservient to her dictation and use them to convert Afghanistan into a proxy and client banana state whose sovereignty lies in the hands of those misled Afghans who claim to have divine rights which can neither be challenged nor changed [due to absence of an theological mechanism].

Thanks to Musharraf, the Afghan Taliban after being stabbed in back by Pakistan army under his leadership will think twice to reject the friendship of India where they have their ideological center [Deoband] in religious terms and which is a growing economy and a regional power unlike Pakistan which neither has any religious significance for Taliban due to Musharraf's policies nor has any politico-economic importance due to its weak economy and unreliable leadership. The only strength Pakistan has its nuclear teeth but according to Dr Perviaz hoodbhoy - a renowned nuclear physicist, it is more a liability than an asset for the Pakistani nation. What good is that muslim brother who devises policies of death ,destruction and devastation for you and calls it Jehad and while lives a luxurious life himelf at the cost of your blood but claims to be your "ansaar" [supporter].

Ban on Afghan Channels in Pakistan

The Afghan channels like Lemar, Shamshad , Tulo etc are no more allowed in Peshawar since September 2010. We are still awaiting the TV channel by Pakhtunkhwa govt while the Khyber TV is the mouth piece of ISPR in Pashto. Some Pashtun ideologues like Sardar Ali Takkar and Jamal Shah wanted to open their own channel but they were refused by the Islamabad 's bureocracy [consiting mostly of Punjabis] due to the vested interests of Khyber TV which is owned by the famous Raja brothers of Punjab.

Sufi Conception of Life

The Sufi's conception of reality is subjective and self conceived and might exist in Plato's "Alam-e- Misaal" [Ideal world] or in their dreams only not in the real world. They claim to have neither any grief about the past not any fear of the future. This only applies to those who have put their efforts to bring progress to a community or humanity at large in the past and who are sure that their efforts will contribute to the evolution of humanity.

Fake Development Projects in Pakistan

The Punjabi elite class in Pakistan always promotes fake propaganda on internet , which is officially dissiminated by all regimes in Pakistan whether they are military [in most cases] or so called democratic govt [in rare cases]. The exploiter class floods internet forums and other media with fake state sponsored propaganda about development to support the autocratic policies of the Punjab dominated Pakistan. They use the technique of disseminating state sponsored news about development projects in Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan ,which are fake and mostly just on papers to give a catharsis to the anger and reaction of Pakhtun and Baloch in Pakistan. It should be known that whenever one reads about a so called development project in Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan, it should be seen as part of propaganda and not a serious effort to give relief to the deprived masses of these two oppressed nations. A country [Pakistan] in which the very basis of the state was fake, the constitution was fake, the source of power [Parliament] is fake, the degrees of the Parliamentarians are fake, the political parties formed over night by intelligence agencies [PML-Q,F,A,N,Z,,,,etc] are fake, the leaders are fake , does this news comes to you as a surprise if we inform you that the so called development projects which you are posting without any shame are fake too. We know it from our first hand experience as we live [and suffer] in Pakhtunkhwa while you copy paste these so called development projects from state sponsored Pakistani Newspapers sitting in your bedroom in US.

Islam and Arab Culture

Believing that Islam and Arabic Language inseparable is believing in Arab imperialism. Following Islam should not mean following Arab culture  if Islam is claimed to be a universal religion otherwise as the reality on ground shows, Islam was and is for Arabs despite its claims for humanity. Islam served the national and political designs of Arabs and also contributed to humanity in its time. It seems to have no more relevant for the contemporary age.

The War in Afpak

There is no war neither in Afghanistan nor in Pakistan. In Afghanistan there is a Pakistan sponsored insurgency and infiltration to control the reigns of power in Kabul. In Pakistan,it is a drama played by the intelligence agencies to keep Pakhtunkwha destablised [and hence under control] and to use the blood of innocent Pakhtuns for getting more dollars from the west. Terrorism is like a virus. Pakistan creates it , yells about its severity and then convinves the world that they have the antivirus. Terrorism is an Arab reactionary phenomenon and the Arab Media like Al Arabia or Al Jazeera is an Arab dominated channel which tries to convince the world that the only issue the world is facing is the Arab or semetic issue.

Political Process in Pakistan

If political process was given a chance in Pakistan and the country was not ruled autocratically by military, then a lot would have been achieved like India but the sheer hegemony of Punjab never let any other institution prosper and they hindered, with the help of their establishment, all those processes and parties which could bring genuine political process into the country to give it a bit oxygen to live to progress.

Drone Strikes

No war is fought in space like a video game that there will not be any casualities. It is not good to condemn Drone attacks due to the collateral damage by NATO forces. This is one of the ways to check the intentions of Pakistan to make Afghanistan its fifth province. This way Afghans will not be used as guinnea pigs for another proxy war by Punjabis and Arabs with the help of sold out religeous demagogues and bigots.

It is however binding on Afghans to stabilise Afghanistan because if you dont keep up with the pace of the world and keep following psychopath and sold out clergymen amongst them instead of listening to the  scholars, scientists, engineers , doctors and technologists etc then they are destined to face the music in various forms.

Targeted Killing of Nationalist - Implications

Whatever propaganda is spread by the Media of Pakistan sold out to the Punjab dominated military and their other loyal slaves about glamourising the armed forces of Pakistan, they forget to realise that the targeted  killing of important Pakhtun and Baloch personalities by military or Taliban is a dangerous game.  The oppressed nations in Pakistan have now realised that their real enemy is the Punjabi civil ,military and political elite. The day is not far when Pakhtuns will stand up to take revenge for every drop of innocent blood shed by these imperialists. Ali, a wise arab scholar said: Al mulku yabqa ma'l kufar wa la yabqa ma'l zulm. [Translation"A country can survive without Islam but cannot surive without Justice".]